Best Desserts at Olive Garden Ranked: Tiramisu vs Chocolate Lasagna (2026)

Best Desserts at Olive Garden Ranked: Tiramisu vs Chocolate Lasagna (2026)

You’ve survived the breadsticks, the Alfredo, the Tour of Italy. Now the most important decision of the evening: dessert. We ranked the best desserts at Olive Garden — including the eternal debate of tiramisu vs. chocolate lasagna — so you can order with confidence.

Note: olivegardensmenue.com/ is an independent guide and is not affiliated with Olive Garden. Prices and availability are as of 2026 and may vary by location.

The Ranking

1. Tiramisu — $8.99 / 470 cal

The undisputed champion. Layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream, dusted with cocoa. It’s the lightest of the heavy hitters at 470 calories, it’s authentically Italian, and it’s the dessert that regulars actually crave between visits. If you only order one dessert here ever, make it this one.

2. Black Tie Mousse Cake — $9.49 / 750 cal

Chocolate cake layered with dark chocolate cheesecake and creamy custard mousse. It’s dramatic, it’s rich, and it’s the best choice for serious chocolate lovers who find the chocolate lasagna a touch gimmicky. Full review here.

3. Chocolate Lasagna — $9.49 / 980 cal

The showman of the menu: layers of chocolate cake, chocolate mousse, and cream. Nearly 1,000 calories of pure theater. It’s fun, it’s shareable, and kids love it — but the tiramisu beats it on actual flavor complexity.

4. Lemon Cream Cake — ~$8.49 / 590 cal

The sleeper pick. Light, citrusy, and the perfect palate cleanser after a heavy Italian meal. If everyone else orders chocolate, be the person who orders this — you’ll have zero regrets.

5. Sicilian Cheesecake — ~$8.99 / 800 cal

A solid ricotta-style cheesecake with strawberry topping. Good, not transcendent — it exists in the shadow of the top three.

Tiramisu vs. Chocolate Lasagna: The Verdict

  • Flavor: Tiramisu wins — espresso + mascarpone has depth; chocolate lasagna is delicious but one-dimensional.
  • Calories: Tiramisu wins big — 470 vs. 980. You could nearly have two tiramisus for one chocolate lasagna.
  • Price: Tiramisu wins — $8.99 vs. $9.49.
  • Shareability: Chocolate lasagna wins — its layered drama is more fun to split.
  • Overall: Tiramisu. It’s not close.

Which Dessert Should YOU Order?

  • First visit? Tiramisu. It’s the signature.
  • Chocoholic? Black Tie Mousse Cake for depth, Chocolate Lasagna for fun.
  • Too full for dessert? Lemon Cream Cake — light enough to finish.
  • Celebrating? Chocolate Lasagna — it’s the most festive-looking.
  • Birthday? It’s free with the eClub birthday offer — order whatever you want.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best dessert at Olive Garden?

Tiramisu ($8.99/470 cal) — the best balance of authentic flavor, reasonable calories, and price.

How much is the chocolate lasagna at Olive Garden?

$9.49 with about 980 calories as of 2026.

Does Olive Garden have free dessert on birthdays?

Yes — eClub members get a free dessert offer for their birthday. Sign up at least 2–3 weeks ahead.

Which Olive Garden dessert has the least calories?

Tiramisu at 470 calories is the lightest of the signature desserts.

Can you get dessert to go?

Yes — all desserts are available for takeout.

olivegardensmenue.com/ is an independent guide and is not affiliated with Olive Garden. Menu items, prices, and nutrition may vary by location.

Similar Posts